The Top Madonna Albums Ranked Worst to Best

Few figures in music are as recognizable, iconic, or controversial as Madonna. Often dubbed the “queen of pop,” her career has spanned forty years of reinvention and innovation. With so many different eras and personas crafted by the enigmatic pop legend, you might be curious to see Madonna albums ranked. Join me as I look through her discography, which is full of some underrated gems.

Madonna Albums Ranked (TLDR)

Coming in first place on the list is 1998’s Ray of Light for its seamless blend of numerous genres, its upbeat songwriting, and stellar production. Last place goes to 2012’s MDNA for its cookie cutter pop songwriting and production, as well as Madonna’s failure to innovate like on her other albums. 

14. MDNA (2012)

Up until this point in Madonna’s career, each of her albums had at least moved into some uncharted territory for the pop star. MDNA feels more like a regression, taking the bland songwriting and style of previous album Hard Candy and adding a strong dose of EDM influence. As a result, a lot of the songs end up sounding the same, and nearly identical to the pop trends of the era.

Favorite Song on MDNA: “Girl Gone Wild” is a fun and energetic dance number with a pulsating beat. Unfortunately, the album quickly grows tiresome afterwards.

• You May Also Like: Black Sabbath Albums Ranked

13. Hard Candy (2008)

Featuring contributions from Pharrell Williams and Justin Timberlake, this album had all the makings of a success. Despite good sales—it is, after all, a Madonna album—the material doesn’t quite hold up. The late 2000’s dance-pop style wears thin over the course of the album’s one hour runtime. 

Favorite Song on Hard Candy: “Candy Shop” is a catchy pop tune with a strong Justin Timberlake sound to it.

12. Rebel Heart (2015)

While the Nicki Minaj collaboration “B***h I’m Madonna” goes down as one of Madonna’s most embarrassing tracks, the album’s general shift to a more stripped-down pop-oriented sound is a good thing overall. The overproduced EDM sound of MDNA is replaced with more elements of 90’s house and trance music. 

Favorite Song on Rebel Heart: “Holy Water” rehashes familiar lyrical ground for Madonna, lending commentary on topics like Catholic guilt and loss of innocence. The rebellious themes combined with the propelling electronic rhythms give this song a classic Madonna feel.

• You May Also Like: AC/DC Albums Ranked

11. Madame X (2019)

Madonna’s most recent studio album deserves props for being her most musically ambitious release in over a decade, but not everything lands here. There are some stinkers like “B***h I’m Loca,” but there’s an eclectic blend of different musical styles here that keep the album surprising and entertaining, incorporating influences from Latin and world music.

Favorite Song on Madame X: “Dark Ballet” is another empowering track exploring themes of religious oppression. This is one of Madonna’s darker and more experimental songs, even sampling Tchaikovsky’s The Nutcracker. 

10. American Life (2003)

While American Life is a lyrically ambitious undertaking that features Madonna decrying materialism and criticizing societal norms, the album’s exploration of the world of folk-influenced electronic pop doesn’t always hit a home run. 

The unique production style featuring glitch effects and jarring stops and starts to the music are interesting, but can wear thin towards the end.

Favorite Song on American Life: “Nothing Fails” is one of the comparatively mellow tracks on the album, a tranquil and reflective acoustic-driven number about love that stands out among the rest of the songs for its gospel influence.

• You May Also Like: Fleetwood Mac Albums Ranked

9. Confessions on a Dance Floor (2005)

An intentional left-turn from the relative seriousness of American Life, this album is pure pop. Every song is upbeat, high energy electronic dance pop. This album manages to incorporate disco influences and R&B rhythms with more of the electronic sound Madonna was known for at this point. 

Favorite Song on Confessions on a Dance Floor: “Get Together” is a fist-pumping and anthemic club stomper. A lot of the pop being produced today still sounds like this song, although no one creates uplifting pop quite like Madonna.

8. Music (2000)

Enter Madonna’s “cowgirl” persona era, although don’t let the cowboy hat fool you—while there is a slight country influence on this album, most of the record takes its cues from the electronic scene at the time. 

After a string of more laid-back albums in the 90’s, Music brings back the dance party feel of old school Madonna while also featuring some experimental influences. The songwriting isn’t quite as strong as her previous work, but it’s a satisfying album.

Favorite Song on Music: “I Deserve It” is a laid-back acoustic track, but it combines its acoustic riff with a catchy hip-hop beat and some experimental synth work. It’s just one of those songs that proves Madonna can accomplish any combination of styles she wants to when she puts her mind to it.

7. Madonna (1983)

Madonna’s eponymous debut embodied the feminine side of the post-disco movement, showing that a woman could hold her own with the likes of Michael Jackson and Prince. While Madonna’s songwriting skills weren’t always fully formed by this point, there are some undeniable classics here. 

Favorite Song on Madonna: “Holiday” is a well-known song, but this uplifting dance hit has remained popular for a reason. This is a fun pop classic that manages to stay entertaining for its six-minute run time. 

• You May Also Like: Led Zeppelin Albums Ranked

6. Bedtime Stories (1994)

An overlooked album upon its release due to the controversy surrounding Madonna’s Sex book, Bedtime Stories is a more innocent and reflective album. While building on the electronic influences Madonna had been incorporating for a few years, this record moves the singer in an R&B direction. Songs like “Don’t Stop” and “I’d Rather Be Your Lover” are picture perfect R&B pop tracks.

Favorite Song on Bedtime Stories: “Bedtime Stories” is a haunting electropop track Madonna cowrote with Icelandic pop eccentric Bjork. This song has an undeniable groove and catchiness while still sounding fresh and experimental.

5. True Blue (1986)

True Blue is an archetypal synth-pop album, and while it does sound very much a product of its time today, many of these tracks still hold up. Despite some filler, the feminist anthem “Open Your Heart,” the somber and moody “Live to Tell,” and bubblegum deep cut “Where’s the Party” are just a few of the pop classics you’ll find on this one. 

Favorite Song on True Blue: “Open Your Heart” is one of Madonna’s most groundbreaking songs. It’s a rare 80’s pop song where a woman expresses her object of sexual desire, featuring passionate vocals over a pulsating synthpop beat with huge, anthemic drums. 

4. Like a Prayer (1989)

In a bid for artistic respectability, Madonna released an album intended to tackle mature subject matter like reflections on her Catholic upbringing and the importance of family.

On this record Madonna often sounds stern and full of desperation in comparison to the lighthearted fun of previous albums, but it works. There are still some light fun hits like “Express Yourself,” and the album also shows inklings of the R&B influences that would come later in her career.

Favorite Song on Like a Prayer: “Keep It Together” is one of the more upbeat tracks on the album, a collaboration between Madonna and Prince held together by a funky beat and some experimental instrumentation by bongos and congas, giving it a more organic feel. 

• You May Also Like: Pink Floyd Albums Ranked

3. Like a Virgin (1984)

This is the album that propelled Madonna to superstardom. Through Madonna’s tongue-in-cheek theatrics (which critics often failed to understand), Like a Virgin both epitomizes and satirizes the excess of the 1980’s. 

Songs like “Material Girl” and the title track can be read as either explicit celebrations of hedonism or ironic social commentary, but with catchy beats like these it doesn’t really matter. As far as song structure, this album is essentially Madonna’s answer to Thriller, with every song being a well-written pop jam.

Favorite Song on Like a Virgin: “Shoo-Bee-Doo” is a deep cut in the Madonna catalogue, but it’s a textbook 80’s pop hit. This is larger than life, bubblegum-oriented fun that could’ve only been written in the 1980’s. 

2. Erotica (1992)

A controversial and divisive pick for the number two spot, Erotica wasn’t as commercially successful as previous releases, and many longtime Madonna fans felt alienated by her decision to embrace the electronic underground trends of the time. 

For me, this album is a bold career move and admirable reinvention of the artist’s sound. As a huge fan of the UK electronic scene of the late 80’s and early 90’s, hearing Madonna work elements of trance, house, downtempo, and jungle into a pop framework is a treat. While lacking the anthemic pop hits of her 80’s work, Erotica is more about the experience. 

Favorite Song on Erotica: “Deeper and Deeper” is possibly the most shamelessly sexual song on the album, but Madonna sounds so seductive and tranquil, the song never approaches crassness despite its subject matter. This is a song that manages to be dance-oriented and relaxing at the same time.

1. Ray of Light (1998)

Only an artist as daring as Madonna could put out her best record at the age of 40. This album is the culmination of the experiments begun on Erotica and Bedtime Stories taken to their absolute apex. 

Ray of Light is a spiritually uplifting album reliant on ambient soundscapes and layered electronic production, drawing from many of the same influences as Erotica but expanding on them. Ambient composer William Orbit helps the overall sound here, leading to a Madonna album that captures the best of her lighter pop side and her deeper, more artistic side.

Favorite Song on Ray of Light: “Drowned World/Substitute for Love” opens the album in style with a catchy and groovy number underscored by ambient and trip-hop elements. Madonna’s vocals are detached and cool, yet passionate and uplifting. 

Wrapping It Up

Well that’s it—all of notable Madonna albums ranked from worst to first. With an artist as impactful as Madonna, it can be overwhelming figuring out which of her many eras to dive into.

Through all stages of her career, she has penned some of the finest pop songs ever put on tape. She doesn’t get enough credit for her esoteric and experimental influences, so I hope this list provided some guidance for you. 

• If you enjoyed the article, be sure to subscribe to my Devoted to Vinyl YouTube channel and Facebook page.

This article was written by Avery and edited by Michael.